Comparison
Etsy vs Amazon Handmade
Etsy and Amazon Handmade both sell handmade goods, but they charge very differently and reach different shoppers. Here's how they compare on fees, audience, rules, and profit.
Last Updated: June 2026
Reviewed for current platform fees and pricing rules.
Side-by-side comparison
A quick overview of how Etsy and Amazon Handmade stack up on the things that matter most.
| Factor | Etsy | Amazon Handmade |
|---|---|---|
| Selling fees | ~12–13% combined (6.5% transaction + ~3% payment processing). | Flat 15% referral fee (includes payment processing). |
| Listing fee | $0.20 per listing, renews every 4 months. | None. |
| Monthly fee | Free (or $10/month for Etsy Plus). | $39.99/month Pro plan — waived for approved Handmade sellers. |
| Audience | ~92M active buyers, craft-focused. | ~380M+ shoppers, very broad, includes Prime members. |
| Rules | Allows print-on-demand and production partners. | Requires 100% handmade items and an application/approval. |
| Average order value | Lower — buyers expect Etsy pricing. | Higher — often $40–60 per order. |
| Best for | Lower-priced items, branding, community. | Higher-priced items, volume, and Prime reach. |
Pros and cons
Etsy
Pros
- Friendlier for new sellers — quick to set up and list.
- Better for branding and a recognizable shop identity.
- Allows print-on-demand and production partners.
- Strong community of craft-focused buyers.
Cons
- Stacked fees (listing + transaction + payment) compress margins.
- Lower average order value than Amazon.
- Intense competition in popular niches.
- Limited customer data — Etsy owns the relationship.
Amazon Handmade
Pros
- Massive Amazon audience, including Prime shoppers.
- No listing fees — only pay when you sell.
- Higher average order value.
- Pro plan fee waived for Handmade sellers.
Cons
- Flat 15% referral fee is steep on low-priced items.
- Application + 100% handmade requirement excludes POD.
- Brand presence is minimal — Amazon owns the customer.
- Less community feel than Etsy.
Example scenarios
Realistic situations and which platform tends to fit best.
New handmade seller with lower-priced items ($10–25)
Start on Etsy. The 15% Amazon fee bites hard at low price points, and Etsy's traffic is easier to tap into for first sales.
Established maker with higher-priced items ($40+)
Add Amazon Handmade alongside Etsy. The higher average order value absorbs the 15% fee, and Prime exposure adds real reach.
Print-on-demand seller
Etsy only. Amazon Handmade requires fully handmade items and excludes POD.
Brand-focused maker who wants both
List on both, but price Amazon listings a bit higher to cover the 15% fee. Many sellers run both with no exclusivity issues.
Who should choose Etsy?
Sellers with lower-priced items, print-on-demand products, or anyone focused on branding and community. Etsy usually keeps more profit at lower price points and is friendlier for new sellers.
Who should choose Amazon Handmade?
Sellers with higher-priced, fully handmade items who want Amazon's reach and Prime exposure. The flat 15% fee works in your favor on $40+ orders where Etsy's stacked fees can be comparable or worse.
Can you use both?
Yes. Neither requires exclusivity, so many sellers list on both and price a bit higher on Amazon to cover the 15% referral fee.
Frequently asked questions
- Is Etsy cheaper than Amazon Handmade?
- On low-priced items, usually yes — Amazon's flat 15% fee is steep on a $15 product. Once average order value climbs above $30–40, total fees often even out.
- Does Amazon Handmade allow print-on-demand?
- No. Amazon Handmade requires items to be made by hand. Print-on-demand sellers should stick with Etsy or list standard products on Amazon's regular marketplace.
- Do I need to be approved for Amazon Handmade?
- Yes — Amazon Handmade requires an application, and you must show that items are genuinely handmade. Etsy has no application.
- Can I sell on both platforms?
- Yes. Neither requires exclusivity. Just keep inventory in sync, and price Amazon a little higher to cover the 15% referral fee.
- Which has more traffic?
- Amazon has roughly 4x more shoppers overall, but Etsy's audience is specifically looking for handmade and craft items, which often converts better for makers.
Related calculators
Put the comparison into numbers for your own shop.
Related guides
Plain-English deep dives that pair with this comparison.
Seller hub
Etsy Seller Hub
Calculators and guides for Etsy shop owners.
All seller tools
Browse every calculator and guide
Etsy, KDP, print-on-demand, and more.
More comparisons
Etsy vs Shopify
Marketplace traffic vs full brand control — which fits your shop?
Printify vs Printful
Lower base costs vs higher quality and integrations — POD compared.
KDP vs IngramSpark
Amazon reach vs bookstore distribution — self-publishing platforms compared.
Redbubble vs TeePublic
Two POD marketplaces, two payout models — which pays artists more?
KDP vs Draft2Digital
Amazon exclusivity vs wide distribution — ebook publishing compared.
eBay vs Facebook Marketplace
Shipped nationwide vs sold locally — which marketplace fits you?
eBay vs Mercari
Stacked fees and global reach vs flat 10% and a simpler flow.
Shopify vs eBay
Owned storefront vs marketplace reach — fees, traffic, and customer ownership compared.
eBay vs Etsy
General marketplace vs handmade-focused buyers — fees and fit compared.
eBay Store vs No Store
When the monthly subscription starts paying for itself — break-even compared.
IngramSpark vs. KDP: Print Cost & What You Keep
Reconcile dollars-per-copy on KDP and IngramSpark — print cost, wholesale discount, and break-evens.
Related Guides
How Much Does Etsy Charge?
A plain-English breakdown of Etsy's listing, transaction, and payment processing fees — and what they cost you per sale.
Read guide →Are Etsy Ads Worth It?
How to tell whether your Etsy Ads are making money or quietly losing it.
Read guide →Do Etsy Sellers Need to Collect Sales Tax?
The short answer is usually no — Etsy handles it. Here's what that means and what you still need to do.
Read guide →
Related Calculators
Etsy Fee Calculator
Estimate Etsy fees before listing a product.
Try calculator →Etsy Profit Calculator
See your true profit after Etsy fees.
Try calculator →Profit Margin Calculator
Universal profit, margin, and markup for any product or channel.
Try calculator →
Compare Alternatives
Help Me Decide
Should You Start an Etsy Shop?
A clear-eyed look at whether Etsy is the right first marketplace for your product — fees, traffic, competition, and the kinds of sellers who actually do well there.
Read decision guide →
Troubleshooting
Why Are My Etsy Ads Not Converting?
If your Etsy Ads are getting clicks but no sales, the problem is almost always one of four things — targeting, listing fit, price, or post-click experience. Here's how to find the broken link.
Read fix →
Case Studies
Etsy Sales Dropped 40%: What Should You Fix First?
A 2-year-old printables shop watched monthly sales fall from $4,000 to $2,400 over six weeks. Here's how to triage the drop using only data Etsy already gives you.
Read case study →
Recommended Downloads
Etsy Conversion Rate Worksheet
A practical workbook for diagnosing low-converting listings and improving Etsy sales performance.
Open resource →Etsy Digital Product Launch Planner
A step-by-step planner for launching a digital product on Etsy — research, listing, SEO, pricing, and launch-week promotion.
Open resource →Etsy Fee Cheat Sheet
A quick reference for the fees that can affect each Etsy sale.
Open resource →